When you first play a KISS song and hear that iconic guitar sound and the call-and-response chant, it’s hard not to get involved. KISS has had a huge impact on rock music, but fans and critics often disagree on which song is their best. In this article, we’ll look at the debate from three angles: fan favorites, chart success, and songs that have stood the test of time. We’ll cover both the classic makeup years and the bold nonmakeup era. You might find that the ultimate KISS anthem depends on which part of their story you love the most.
KISS is a powerhouse in the music world. They’ve sold over 30 gold records, more than any other U.S. band. This success has given them a catalog full of hits. When fans are asked, a few songs always come up: “Rock and Roll All Nite,” a concert favorite that often tops fan lists; “Detroit Rock City,” a beloved story of a fan on the way to a show; and deep cuts like “Cold Gin” and “Strutter,” known for their raw energy. Then there’s “I Was Made for Lovin’ You,” which features one of their most famous choruses, often heard at stadiums and parties.
In the 1980s, KISS took off their makeup and embraced a new sound. This era brought its own classics. Recent polls show that “Unholy” is the top pick from this time. Released in 1992, it reached No. 2 in Norway and charted worldwide.
Here are the top five nonmakeup songs that fans love:
1. “Unholy” – A heavy track co-written by Gene Simmons and Vinnie Vincent.
2. “Lick It Up” – An MTV favorite with a standout performance by Paul Stanley.
3. “Forever” – A ballad co-written with Desmond Child, it was the highest-charting single from the Crazy Nights album.
4. “I Still Love You” – A complex rock ballad that gained a cult following.
5. “Lick It Up” – KISS’s first single without makeup, showcasing their new style.

